Selection Approval Logs: Products, Allowances, and Customer Signoff
Keep approved products, spec sheets, allowance changes, ordering authority, substitutions, and installation checks in one selection approval log.

For example, a customer texts “matte black is fine.” The supplier stocks two faucet models in that finish, and only one fits the planned installation. A finish preference is not a complete purchasing instruction.
A selection approval log should identify the exact product, specification sheet, allowance, decision, approver, and purchasing status. Use Documentorium's scope attachment for accepted selections and a submittal register when construction review is part of the workflow. Keep a stable selection ID through the separate log, purchasing records, and installation; a finish preference alone is incomplete.
Make one row describe one decision
The log should be specific enough for someone who missed the showroom visit to order correctly.
| Record | What belongs there |
|---|---|
| Location and identity | Room, installation position, brand, model, finish code, size, quantity, and other material specifications |
| Attachments | Dated product data, installation instructions, dimensions, included accessories, warranty, and representative sample where useful |
| Price treatment | Base scope, allowance, overage, credit, tax, freight, installation effect, and applicable change reference |
| Timing | Decision deadline, confirmed availability, expected delivery, and schedule dependencies |
| Authority | Named approver, role, date, revision, and approval for purchase, installation, or both |
| Status | Proposed, technical review pending, customer approved, ordered, received, installed, or superseded |
Do not rely on a retailer's changing web page as the only specification. Save the relevant version with its source. Use a representative finish sample when appearance depends on the substrate and application method; the cabinet-painting proposal guide explains that approval boundary.
Check fit and responsibility before release
Customer selection and technical acceptance answer different questions. Check required clearances, connections, supports, compatibility, manufacturer instructions, and applicable approvals before purchase or installation. A customer cannot authorize an unsuitable or unlawful installation merely by accepting its appearance.
For owner-furnished products, record who orders, delivers, checks completeness, handles damage and returns, and administers product claims. State how missing parts or late delivery will be addressed. Use the customer-supplied material scope workflow to define the inspection and approval gate without disclaiming responsibility for the contractor's own work.
Identify the decision maker. A tenant may choose color while the owner must approve cost; a designer's product review may not authorize a budget increase. Resolve those limits in the agreement before a special order is placed.
Separate an allowance from the chosen item
An allowance is a pricing provision. It does not identify the approved product or establish what related labor is included.
For an illustrative selection, the estimate might carry $600 for a fixture. The chosen product costs $680, with $25 freight and a different mounting requirement. Record the allowance's agreed basis, actual adjustment, and added labor before approval. Do not present the $80 material difference as the entire change if other costs also change.
Use a change order where scope, price, contract time, or other terms require modification. Follow the approval-before-work guide. Do not use a selection signature to conceal a financial change.
Give substitutions a fresh identity
When the approved product becomes unavailable, record the original and proposed substitute, reason, visible differences, technical effects, warranty, price, and timing. Obtain the required approval before the next commitment. Preserve the superseded selection and its approval.
Carry the accepted ID and revision into the purchase order. On the delivery record, compare actual labels, quantities, finish, condition, and included parts with that order. Hold a mismatch rather than installing the nearest available item.
The work order should identify the approved product and unresolved hold points. A showroom conversation should not force the installer to guess.
Keep the log connected to the contract
Some jurisdictions require particular material descriptions and signed changes. New York GBS 771 addresses covered home-improvement contracts, amendments, and identifying material information. Maryland's guidance requires descriptions of materials and incorporated documents. California's CSLB contract guidance emphasizes detailed products and written changes. A practical log supports those requirements but does not replace them.
The FTC warranty guide explains covered consumer-product warranty disclosures and presale availability. Provide the applicable terms before the sale; distinguish manufacturer coverage from workmanship coverage.
ESIGN section 7001 recognizes electronic records while preserving other requirements. Keep the approved content, attachments, identity, date, and action reproducible. At completion, reconcile installed products, approved substitutions, credits, open items, manuals, and warranties.
Common questions
Is a selection log the same as a change order?
No. It identifies choices and approvals. Use the required contract modification when a choice changes price, scope, time, or other agreed terms.
When should approval be obtained?
Before the first commitment requiring it, such as a nonreturnable purchase, custom fabrication, allowance overage, or installation. State exactly what the approval releases.
What if the delivered model differs?
Hold the item, compare the difference with the approved specification, complete technical review, and obtain required revised approval before installation.
Useful documents for this job
Related blog posts
- Estimate Scope Attachments: Hidden Conditions and Customer Materials
- Change Orders: Get the Signature Before the Extra Work Starts
- Cabinet Painting Proposals: Scope, Finish Samples, and Cure Time
- Written Quotes for Contractors: Scope, Price, and Approval Records
- PDF Workflow for Contractors: From Quote to Sign-Off
- Work Order Photo Checklist: Before, During, After, and Exceptions
- Final Walkthrough Before Final Payment: What to Check Before You Bill
- Manufacturer Warranty Pass-Throughs: Parts, Labor, and Shop Obligations
- Material Takeoff Reconciliation: Field Use, Returns, and Variances
- Schedule Change Notices: Dates, Causes, and Approval Records